Finding Good Horror Stories
I know what I like to read. I know that if I pick up a fantasy book I’ll probably enjoy it, in fact I probably don’t need to read the synopsis. I can pick up a sci-fi book, read the synopsis and make an intelligent decision about reading it (perfect track record too). I can do the same thing with mysteries (though these days I’m sick and tired of murder mysteries so my reading in that area has slacked off). Everything has been rosy, except for horror stories; I’ve been real hit-or-miss, even with reading the synopsis. I have my suspicions for why I’m failing.
Allow me to invoke Lovecraft yet again, for his stories are a shining example of what I’m looking for in horror stories. First and foremost Lovecraft didn’t write horror; he considered his stories “weird fiction” (two of his essays claim that anyway). I don’t read stories to scare myself, I just don’t think it’s possible. But I do like reading weird stories; for me it’s another aspect of imaginative fantasy; it’s another escape into the unknown away from the mundane.
Now it seems to me that a good synopsis of your average horror story will in some way spoil the story. You can’t ruin the suspense of a story without ruining the story, and from my reading most horror stories are about that “Gotcha!” moment, and so often it is that moment that turns me off to the story with a “too lame” comment.
Could it be that I can’t find a good horror story because good horror is hard to come by? Could it be that I need to find a better classification for what I want to read (weird fiction)? It is just too hard to give readers advance warning about a horror story without giving it away? Or is horror too encompassing as a classification and thus it will always have the problem of finding readers. A ghost story isn’t a monster story, nor a vampire chasing werewolves story; horror, like fantasy, is a broad category which can encompass many themes.
In the end maybe the problem is all about theme and thematic elements. Maybe that’s all it is, or maybe it’s still more than that. Thoughts?
Disclaimer: I have read far more fantasy and sci-fi than horror. This could very well be an anomaly due to lack of exposure.